View previous topic :: View next topic |
Author |
Message |
Chen Kenichi Registered User
Joined: 15 Dec 2001 Location: DFW Posts: 1136
|
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2003 2:09 am Post subject: Factions and Faith |
|
|
Earlier today I dusted off an old copy of The Book of Virtues I own and browsed through the section concerning faith. It announced that faith is not wholly a religious trait, but familiar to any type of faction. When I set the book down, I jumbled around a few ideas in my head, but couldn't really make sense of anything, and decided to post the product here. These are simply the ramblings of a tired man thirsting for perspicacity.
I'll start with a few acknowledgments before moving to my questions. Forgive my lack of transitions, but please contest any of these:
I believe James Madison wrote in Federalist 10 that it is human nature to assimilate into factions. Factions satisfy the need for belonging and appeal to those who share similar beliefs. Factions generally have an idea of how society should be and presume others should adhere to their concept. Many set forth action to change society and end up clashing with other factions in the process.
Faith is the most controlling and controversial "virtue" of them all. Faith can defy logic, reason, and truth. Faith can indubitably affix oneself the right and an adversary in the wrong. If the leading patrons of faith are militant, disaster may check in.
A popular bandwagon to catch a ride on condemns religion for generating abundant strife in the world, even though it supposedly has divine influence. Religion is the strongest proponent of faith, and religious leaders justify wars by means of it. It is in human nature to believe without concrete justification, although education significantly helps contain it.
Now, to create (or at least take steps toward) a utopian society, it would seem humans would have to devoid themselves of faith. Fanatical faith in conjuction with faction confirmedly yields calamity. The most prominent example of faith and faction is religion. But, if the world was purged of all religion, would there be a type of supplementary faction to make up for the absence of it? Or more generally speaking, could humans devoid themselves of aggressive factions altogether? Can a faction exist without the slightest element of faith? Is the alliance of faith and faction the cause of all wars?
[/ramble] Feel free to reply with whatever. I made a duplicate thread at the Catacombs if you ever browse there. _________________
Last edited by Chen Kenichi on Sun Dec 07, 2003 3:07 am; edited 1 time in total |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Violent Pacifist Registered User
Joined: 29 Dec 2001 Location: Ft. Worth, TX Posts: 1776
|
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2003 2:50 am Post subject: |
|
|
I don't think a utopian society could ever come into being in our world. Faith is one of the things woven into human nature forever. There will always be someone who believes in a god or a better future. There will always be someone who believes that everything and anything that happens does so for a reason. There will also always be someone is ready to abuse these kinds of faith.
Throughout history the world has witnessed dictators build foundations of religions around themselves. Hitler rose to power by spewing force propaganda, and destroying all opposition in his way. Once atop the throne, he promised better futures for his people by purging a specified enemy, Jews, and non-believers of "Nazism". Because of the terrible poverty Germany was currently in, such an act had them estatic about their new leader. Stalin managed the same thing by killing all of his opposition, and "enemies of the people" (communist party members, army members, entire towns, etc.). He re-wrote Russian history so that it looked as if he had played a much larger role in Russia's ascesion to power. Both of these dictators were able to obtain and abuse their peoples' faith with promises that did not follow any logic whatsoever.
To abolish faith from society is impossible. A person/s would first have to come to power in order to unite the people (unless different leaders are acting together, "the people" would have to refer to the world population). However, doing so immediatly creates a faith around that leader. As in any faith/faction, another person will develop ideas of their own, and spread them to others as well. This new faction will either split off from the original, or try to overthrow its predecessor. No matter which way it chooses to go, one faction after another will rise up against the other.
I think the closest our world would ever be able to come to a utopia can be seen in 1984. But the source of that utopia is based on faith for big brother, the ministry, and all the principles they stand for. (What a sad utopia that'd be if it ever came true too ) _________________
We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Pornstar Registered User
Joined: 12 Aug 2001 Location: Arlington, TX Posts: 1153
|
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2003 5:12 am Post subject: Re: Factions and Faith |
|
|
Chen Kenichi wrote: | Earlier today I dusted off an old copy of The Book of Virtues I own and browsed through the section concerning faith. It announced that faith is not wholly a religious trait, but familiar to any type of faction. When I set the book down, I jumbled around a few ideas in my head, but couldn't really make sense of anything, and decided to post the product here. These are simply the ramblings of a tired man thirsting for perspicacity.
I'll start with a few acknowledgments before moving to my questions. Forgive my lack of transitions, but please contest any of these:
I believe James Madison wrote in Federalist 10 that it is human nature to assimilate into factions. Factions satisfy the need for belonging and appeal to those who share similar beliefs. Factions generally have an idea of how society should be and presume others should adhere to their concept. Many set forth action to change society and end up clashing with other factions in the process.
Faith is the most controlling and controversial "virtue" of them all. Faith can defy logic, reason, and truth. Faith can indubitably affix oneself the right and an adversary in the wrong. If the leading patrons of faith are militant, disaster may check in.
A popular bandwagon to catch a ride on condemns religion for generating abundant strife in the world, even though it supposedly has divine influence. Religion is the strongest proponent of faith, and religious leaders justify wars by means of it. It is in human nature to believe without concrete justification, although education significantly helps contain it.
Now, to create (or at least take steps toward) a utopian society, it would seem humans would have to devoid themselves of faith. Fanatical faith in conjuction with faction confirmedly yields calamity. The most prominent example of faith and faction is religion. But, if the world was purged of all religion, would there be a type of supplementary faction to make up for the absence of it? Or more generally speaking, could humans devoid themselves of aggressive factions altogether? Can a faction exist without the slightest element of faith? Is the alliance of faith and faction the cause of all wars?
[/ramble] Feel free to reply with whatever. I made a duplicate thread at the Catacombs if you ever browse there. |
This is what Socialism/Communism strive for. If you irredicate Indivualism, then in theory you would have an utopian society since all different beliefs and ideals are conformed to one belief system. Quite frankly you cannot have an universal utopian society. It can work in small groups of people that share the same beliefs and strive for the same goals. In the US we have a (or what use to be)Republican form of governement. Through this type of goevernment, the people impowered elected officials to protect our beliefs. Irregardless of the differences. By giving everybody equal footing in society, you are able to create your own utopian society as long as it does not infringe on somebody elses rights. As far as religion goes. There are religions that were based on evilness and destruction, and then there are religions that are peacefull. A lot people out there claim religions like Christianity caused many wars and repression. The truth is Christianity is a peacefull religion. The problem is that individuals sieze upon these beliefs and use it and the people that follow it for their own personal gain and agenda. If you look at the history of the Roman Catholic Church over the pass 2,000+ years. You will see this trend. As Westerns moved away from Monarchies towards Self-Government you will see how the Church has changed over the years.
On religion read How the Irish Saved Civilization by Thomas Cahill. It talks about the fall of Rome in 432 AD and the power vaccum that occured afterwards. He talks of the emerging of the two Catholic Churchs (Roman and Irish) and the difference in between the Roman based on St. Augustine's view of Christianity and the Irish based on St. Patricus view. The Irish Catholic Church would eventually bend to the Roman version several centuries later. The Roman version was a opressive one that ruled through warlords that would become Kings. The Irish version adapted itself to the Irish Pagan religion and was very open. If you study the 2,000+ years of history of the Roman Catholic Church. You will see how it evolved over time to a more open faith, from Divine Monarchy to Self-Rule time period. Cahill makes a point on if the Irish Catholism had prevailed that the Dark Ages would have never occured.We would not have had to relearn writen language, Republican form of Government, freedom of thought and much of history would not of been lost. St. Augustine had any Latin material that spoke of the old Roman Gods or any other subject he disagreed with destroyed. Many of Cicero's works were lost due to this. If it wasn't for Ancient Greek or the Irish Monks who salvaged any Latin works. Much of the Roman Empire history would be lost to us. The Irish Monks copied the Latin books and even created a writen version of Celtic. Most people don't know that Ireland was the intellectual power from 500 AD through 1200 AD. Most of the Nobility of emerging European countries sent their children their to be educated in Latin and history. Ireland would eventually fall due to the constant raiding by the Vikings. After 1200 AD the Vikings had pretty much controlled most of Ireland and establish their first cities such as Dublin. The funny thing is that the Vikings would similate into the Irish culture, not the other way around.
Due to the raidings much of the writen material was burried to keep from it being destroyed by the Vikings. It is said that farmers still pull up old Latin texts when plowing their fields. you can even find families that have journals that date back to 400s/500s and the families continue to add on to them and then pass them down as hierlooms. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
ROOFCUTTER Server Admin
Joined: 12 Aug 2001 Location: =USV= Posts: 9271
|
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2003 5:19 am Post subject: |
|
|
I have faith that the lust for power will always win.
I have faith that being born to a settled safe time and a troubled stress time is only a matter of timing.
the act of not having faith is an act of faith in itself.
faith will follow any path.
faith and religion are not only innertwined but have nothing to do with each other.
I find it strange that the drive for control and power is just the result of a chemical reaction during development.
I find the time line of human kind is a large wheel of stages that press us into molds, you have to line your self up just right to hit a comfort zone.
Quote: | I don't think a utopian society could ever come into being in our world | It would never last long. the very person who believes in it, has a basic instint that is not to mess with others. another person will not only mess with others but thinks its his right to. No society utopian or not can last.
Utopian is a state of mind not a place or people. In a world of madness I live a Utopian life, sums it up for me.
Quote: | To abolish faith from society is impossible. A person/s would first have to come to power in order to unite the people |
This will happen in time. technology will find a way to kill all the people except the ones "choosen" you cant abolish faith but you can kill the faithful. the remaining will define the meaning of faith.
I have faith that this is just 3 am babble and can be summed up in a few words.
shit happens. has happened and will always happen. hope you live between wipes. _________________ Only in America......do they have drive-up ATM machines with Braille lettering. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Mr.Kason Allen Registered User
Joined: 06 Dec 2002 Location: Somewhere over a rainbow Posts: 1002
|
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2003 10:46 am Post subject: |
|
|
ROOFCUTTER wrote: |
shit happens. has happened and will always happen. hope you live between wipes. |
Think somebody could have posted this a while ago _________________ Over your dead body! |
|
Back to top |
|
|
Violent Pacifist Registered User
Joined: 29 Dec 2001 Location: Ft. Worth, TX Posts: 1776
|
Posted: Sun Dec 07, 2003 1:13 pm Post subject: |
|
|
You'd have to kill the entire world to abolish all faith, roof _________________
We are the music makers, and we are the dreamers of dreams. |
|
Back to top |
|
|
|
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum You cannot vote in polls in this forum
|
Powered by phpBB © 2001, 2005 phpBB Group
|